What shocks me most about this article is not that American citizens or those who are eligible for citizenship, meaning only those who were “white”, did this but that the government in countries such as China, Japan and Korea allowed their citizens to be used in such a manner. Why would the government of these countries allow their citizens to be treated like slaves and continue to send individuals at the demands of the employers? Why were more governments not like that of the Korean government who eventually prohibited further immigration to Hawaii because of the way that their citizens were being treated? Its article such as this one that make it so easy to point fingers on just one group of people when in all actuality the fault is everywhere. Why would the employers stop treating their workers that why when they are getting extremely high levels of productivity at low cost and other countries are allowing their citizens to do it? Why would they stop if everyone was supporting their actions?
In the article it talked about how even though all workers were treated very poorly some where discriminated on more than others. On page 255 it talks about how even women were required to do much the same work as men they were paid significantly less. On average women made 55 cents a day while men made 75 cents a day. That was back in the early 1900’s so why is it much the same way today. This only goes to prove that we have made significant strides for equal opportunities in the work place but we still have a long way to go.
Along those same lines the article goes on to talk about the most significant “blood unionism” and the Japanese Strike of 1909. They were in a rage and protesting against the fact that Portuguese laborers were paid more than they were for the same work. They were on strike for four months before they were required to return to work. Even though they returned to work and continued to make different wages than their counterparts from around the world the plantation owners discontinued using the differential wage system because of all of the pressure they felt from the strike.
After the Hawaii Laborers Union was created, a multiracial organization, Plantation owners and leaders tried to turn the different racial groups on each other using black mail and propaganda. Eventually the plantation owners claimed a complete victory but three months later increased wages by 50%.
The issues that the Japanese and others faced in America in the early 1900’s can be blamed on many different things. There are so many outside factors that its impossible to point the finger at any one particular cause.
Sunday, February 25, 2007
Sunday, February 11, 2007
The “Giddy Multitude”
After reading just the first paragraph I realized something. If tomorrow we woke up and saw an individual with purple skin how would we react? What would we do? What would we think? I was amused by the quote about the African’s skin color. It says, “It seemeth this blackness proceedeth rather of some natural infection of that man, which was so strong that neither the nature of the Clime, neither the good complexion of the mother concurring, could anything alter...” It was after reading this that I begin to question what we in present day society would think of someone who we randomly stumbled upon with a different skin color. If we saw someone with purple skin how would we explain it? I believe that we would try and explain it scientifically using modern day technology. Whets the difference between that and the way the whites tried to explain it hundreds of years ago? With the technological limitations was their beliefs and opinion so wrong?
On page 54 it talks about how in the early days of the Virginia colony most “slaves” were actually white indentured servants. It says that during the seventeenth century almost 75 percent of the colonist came as servants. After hearing this fact I find it ironic that we view slavery as a matter of differences in skin color and about people being inferior to others. This fact makes me believe that slavery is not about skin color its about feelings of power. Feelings of power over other people regardless of what their skin color is. Some people may find that its easier to exert this power of people that they view as inferior but I don’t think that skin color is the main factor. Could it be that we use racism as a scapegoat to cover up human greed and selfishness? Is it possible that humans are not generally good and only have their best interest at heart? I think that there are many other “hidden” reasons for slavery that are not often addresses.
It goes on to say that these people who were indentured servants were the outcasts of society. Therefore the people that used them as indentured servants viewed themselves as superior and it was not because of their skin color but rather because of their place in society. So maybe its safe to say that blacks are viewed as inferior to some because of their place in society and not because of their skin color.
What I don’t understand is what happened. Why did blacks then become indentured servants for life while whites were only required to complete a certain amount of time? When did it no longer become an issue of power and an issue of race? Its this mystery that I think deserves more of our time trying to solve than trying to discover while there is slavery in the first place.
On page 54 it talks about how in the early days of the Virginia colony most “slaves” were actually white indentured servants. It says that during the seventeenth century almost 75 percent of the colonist came as servants. After hearing this fact I find it ironic that we view slavery as a matter of differences in skin color and about people being inferior to others. This fact makes me believe that slavery is not about skin color its about feelings of power. Feelings of power over other people regardless of what their skin color is. Some people may find that its easier to exert this power of people that they view as inferior but I don’t think that skin color is the main factor. Could it be that we use racism as a scapegoat to cover up human greed and selfishness? Is it possible that humans are not generally good and only have their best interest at heart? I think that there are many other “hidden” reasons for slavery that are not often addresses.
It goes on to say that these people who were indentured servants were the outcasts of society. Therefore the people that used them as indentured servants viewed themselves as superior and it was not because of their skin color but rather because of their place in society. So maybe its safe to say that blacks are viewed as inferior to some because of their place in society and not because of their skin color.
What I don’t understand is what happened. Why did blacks then become indentured servants for life while whites were only required to complete a certain amount of time? When did it no longer become an issue of power and an issue of race? Its this mystery that I think deserves more of our time trying to solve than trying to discover while there is slavery in the first place.
Tuesday, February 6, 2007
Chapter 2: Drawing the Color Line
Early in Zinn’s article he begins talking about how the past should provide us with a few clues as to how the future should unfold. Will the color line ever completely disappear? In the third paragraph Zinn defines racism as the combination of inferior status and derogatory thought.
After reading this and contemplating this definition I don’t think that it necessarily relates to what the current definition of racism is. Is our current situation in regards to racism really about derogatory thought and inferior status?
In my belief racism has come to represent a misunderstanding and lack of knowledge of how to fix it. In my opinion whites do not view blacks as inferior but rather they have never been taught to view them as equals. For example, if we were taught that chocolate was bad for hundreds of years would we instantly believe that it’s good for you? We have been taught and almost brainwashed into what to believe for so long that it has hazed our thinking. Or is it that we try to hard to cover up our differences that we make it look like we find ourselves to be better or inferior?
For example, affirmative action. Due to the way that we have been raised we felt it necessary to create rules and regulations to promote equal opportunity for different races, genders, and sexualities. If we had been raised slightly different we wouldn’t find it necessary to create laws and regulations creating equal opportunity. Equal opportunity is not created through rules and regulations, it’s through beliefs and values. The color line will never disappear until we stop forcing people to feel a certain way and start becoming more understanding of different cultural values and beliefs.
After reading this and contemplating this definition I don’t think that it necessarily relates to what the current definition of racism is. Is our current situation in regards to racism really about derogatory thought and inferior status?
In my belief racism has come to represent a misunderstanding and lack of knowledge of how to fix it. In my opinion whites do not view blacks as inferior but rather they have never been taught to view them as equals. For example, if we were taught that chocolate was bad for hundreds of years would we instantly believe that it’s good for you? We have been taught and almost brainwashed into what to believe for so long that it has hazed our thinking. Or is it that we try to hard to cover up our differences that we make it look like we find ourselves to be better or inferior?
For example, affirmative action. Due to the way that we have been raised we felt it necessary to create rules and regulations to promote equal opportunity for different races, genders, and sexualities. If we had been raised slightly different we wouldn’t find it necessary to create laws and regulations creating equal opportunity. Equal opportunity is not created through rules and regulations, it’s through beliefs and values. The color line will never disappear until we stop forcing people to feel a certain way and start becoming more understanding of different cultural values and beliefs.
Sunday, February 4, 2007
How Systems of Privilege Work
In this chapter Johnson addresses the basic foundation of privilege. Johnson says that there are three characteristics of systems organized around privilege. Those characteristics include dominated, identified and centered by privilege groups. All of these characteristics support that belief that all members of privilege groups are better than those that are below them and they deserve to be there. He also states that white men have most of the power. He uses the example of a business and how the further up you look the more men you see and the further down you look the more women you see. He calls our current society a male-dominated system. It was interesting to hear that evidence that Johnson had for how our society is dominated by males. He talks about how many derogatory comments there are for men who are dominated by woman but there aren’t many for women who are dominated by men. He also stated how men are criticized if they don’t live up to the typical expectations given by male power. Another great example was when he talked about the term brotherhood and how it is commonly used and would never be replaced with words such as sisterhood.
After reading this chapter there isn’t anything that I question. Issues of gender are very present in today society and are directly related to privilege. My favorite example of this is when Johnson talks about how high-status occupations and how the core competencies required for these positions are based around masculine qualities such as competition, aggressiveness and not being emotional attached. It’s unfortunate that our society has to stereotype different genders but I don’t see any way around it. In our society it’s extremely difficult to be a women and working in a mans world. It’s interesting to think about why women have such a strong disadvantage but if you think about all of the opportunities that they don’t have its not surprising. One of the most interesting ideas that I have heard about this is how in business women do not have access to some of the most important place business deals occur and that is the golf course. It’s interesting that men have created a double disadvantage without even realizing it. Not only are women at a disadvantage to men because they don’t have the same qualities as men when it comes to business but they are now also at a disadvantage physical because they don’t normal play on the same level as men. I believe that most men would be irritated if they were playing golf with a women and she was not at the same skill level as he.
It’s interesting to when all the facts are laid out because I think that its something that in our day to day lives we tend to over look.
After reading this chapter there isn’t anything that I question. Issues of gender are very present in today society and are directly related to privilege. My favorite example of this is when Johnson talks about how high-status occupations and how the core competencies required for these positions are based around masculine qualities such as competition, aggressiveness and not being emotional attached. It’s unfortunate that our society has to stereotype different genders but I don’t see any way around it. In our society it’s extremely difficult to be a women and working in a mans world. It’s interesting to think about why women have such a strong disadvantage but if you think about all of the opportunities that they don’t have its not surprising. One of the most interesting ideas that I have heard about this is how in business women do not have access to some of the most important place business deals occur and that is the golf course. It’s interesting that men have created a double disadvantage without even realizing it. Not only are women at a disadvantage to men because they don’t have the same qualities as men when it comes to business but they are now also at a disadvantage physical because they don’t normal play on the same level as men. I believe that most men would be irritated if they were playing golf with a women and she was not at the same skill level as he.
It’s interesting to when all the facts are laid out because I think that its something that in our day to day lives we tend to over look.
Tuesday, January 30, 2007
What it all has to do with us
In this chapter Johnson talks a lot about myths and social construction. He states early on that our society places a strong emphasis on the individual which is more often than not a strong disadvantage because it distorts our view of reality. He also concludes that think only about the individual causes us to play the blame game, always blaming everything in the world on someone else.
Johnson also discusses the idea behind everyone’s personal identity and how that relates to our social systems as a whole rather than the individualistic model. In order to understand what happens in the world you need to know how our social systems behave and interact with individuals, not how individuals act alone.
Another interesting theory that he discusses is the theory of the path of least resistance. After reading about the theory it made perfect sense but it was never something that I realized or identified with before being told about it. As individuals we do what is normally accepted by our social systems and is the easiest for us to do. This concepts just reinforces that its individuals acting within social systems that creates our society.
Once again I do believe that Johnson does a great job of further explaining privilege and oppression in our society today, however, I completely disagree with his statement that, “A University, for example, is a social system, and people participate in it. But the people aren’t the university and the university isn’t the people.” While I think that his intentions are good with this statement I do think that this would be very confusing to many readers. I understand the concept behind what he is saying in regards to individuals and social systems but there is a fine line distinguishing the two. I do believe that a university is the people and that the people are the university. What would a university be without the people behind it? The university is a social system but social systems are nothing without the individuals collectively supporting, creating and nurturing them. If people were not here to support the university what would the university be? If we were not here how different would the university be? If the professors were all different what would our values be? What would our mission statement be if we had a different President?
All of these questions, I think, show how collectively individuals do create the social systems such as Universities.
Johnson also discusses the idea behind everyone’s personal identity and how that relates to our social systems as a whole rather than the individualistic model. In order to understand what happens in the world you need to know how our social systems behave and interact with individuals, not how individuals act alone.
Another interesting theory that he discusses is the theory of the path of least resistance. After reading about the theory it made perfect sense but it was never something that I realized or identified with before being told about it. As individuals we do what is normally accepted by our social systems and is the easiest for us to do. This concepts just reinforces that its individuals acting within social systems that creates our society.
Once again I do believe that Johnson does a great job of further explaining privilege and oppression in our society today, however, I completely disagree with his statement that, “A University, for example, is a social system, and people participate in it. But the people aren’t the university and the university isn’t the people.” While I think that his intentions are good with this statement I do think that this would be very confusing to many readers. I understand the concept behind what he is saying in regards to individuals and social systems but there is a fine line distinguishing the two. I do believe that a university is the people and that the people are the university. What would a university be without the people behind it? The university is a social system but social systems are nothing without the individuals collectively supporting, creating and nurturing them. If people were not here to support the university what would the university be? If we were not here how different would the university be? If the professors were all different what would our values be? What would our mission statement be if we had a different President?
All of these questions, I think, show how collectively individuals do create the social systems such as Universities.
The Trouble with the Trouble
“If dominant groups really saw privilege and oppression as unacceptable –if white people saw race as their issue, if nondisabled people saw ableism as their problem-privilege and oppression wouldn’t have much of a future.”
This is by far my favorite chapter in Privilege, Power and Difference. I can really relate to all of the concepts that Johnson talks about and feel he does a great job of relating these issues to actual business practices today. Johnson concludes that there are a few reasons why people do not actively engage in privilege issues; because they don’t know that it exists in the first place, because they don’t have to, because they think that its just a personal problem, because they want to hang on to their privileges, because they are prejudiced, or because they are afraid. Johnson believes that these reasons are the foundation as to why people ignore issues or privilege. He also concludes that there are two ways that the Human Resource Managers went about dealing with the issue; the first strategy they use is to appeal to the sense of decency and fairness that many privileged people have and the other is the business case often used by corporations and universities.
What most intrigued me about this reading was his discussion of the business case and how it relates to corporations. He argues that implementing diversity programs would cost less in the long run than losing talented and skillful workers who are uncomfortable in their environment. He also states that any attempts businesses make to address diversity are short lived because people are not dedicated to the cause.
While I completely agree with Johnson’s argument I do question how accurate his assumptions are about diversity in the workplace. Ever since Affirmative Action became a requirement I think tremendous strides have been taken to implement diversity programs and considerations into corporations. I recently attended the Owens Corning Diversity Leadership Conference where we addressed many of these same issues. Owens Corning does a fabulous job of creating programs that enhance diversity across their global organization and they do so for many reasons. As a generalization I don’t believe that organizations implement diversity programs ONLY for reasons as stated in the business case. I do agree that organizations are forced to implement these standards to stay competitive but I also believe that after implementation these standards have significantly improved the quality of life for their employees and for their customers. It is becoming a global trend to support diversity amongst employees because it makes the organization better as whole. I think that stating that these are the first programs to get cut in a budget crunch is a false assumption because many organizations now realize the overall importance of these programs to their success.
I really enjoyed this reading. I’m a business major and a lot of the topics that were discussed in this reading I have discussed before in my classes. Johnson also states, “Even when people can see the benefits somewhere off in the distance, they still need something to hold them to the vision and see them through the long journey from here to there. Appealing to lofty principles or the bottom line can’t do it, because those approaches too easily give way to forces and considerations that are powerful in the short run even if they are disastrous in the long run.”
I could not disagree with this statement more. Our society is based on bottom lines and lofty principles. Our economy would not be the same; we would not be such a wealthy and prosperous nation if we weren’t based on those things. Johnson does a great job making his argument but I disagree with some of his statements.
This is by far my favorite chapter in Privilege, Power and Difference. I can really relate to all of the concepts that Johnson talks about and feel he does a great job of relating these issues to actual business practices today. Johnson concludes that there are a few reasons why people do not actively engage in privilege issues; because they don’t know that it exists in the first place, because they don’t have to, because they think that its just a personal problem, because they want to hang on to their privileges, because they are prejudiced, or because they are afraid. Johnson believes that these reasons are the foundation as to why people ignore issues or privilege. He also concludes that there are two ways that the Human Resource Managers went about dealing with the issue; the first strategy they use is to appeal to the sense of decency and fairness that many privileged people have and the other is the business case often used by corporations and universities.
What most intrigued me about this reading was his discussion of the business case and how it relates to corporations. He argues that implementing diversity programs would cost less in the long run than losing talented and skillful workers who are uncomfortable in their environment. He also states that any attempts businesses make to address diversity are short lived because people are not dedicated to the cause.
While I completely agree with Johnson’s argument I do question how accurate his assumptions are about diversity in the workplace. Ever since Affirmative Action became a requirement I think tremendous strides have been taken to implement diversity programs and considerations into corporations. I recently attended the Owens Corning Diversity Leadership Conference where we addressed many of these same issues. Owens Corning does a fabulous job of creating programs that enhance diversity across their global organization and they do so for many reasons. As a generalization I don’t believe that organizations implement diversity programs ONLY for reasons as stated in the business case. I do agree that organizations are forced to implement these standards to stay competitive but I also believe that after implementation these standards have significantly improved the quality of life for their employees and for their customers. It is becoming a global trend to support diversity amongst employees because it makes the organization better as whole. I think that stating that these are the first programs to get cut in a budget crunch is a false assumption because many organizations now realize the overall importance of these programs to their success.
I really enjoyed this reading. I’m a business major and a lot of the topics that were discussed in this reading I have discussed before in my classes. Johnson also states, “Even when people can see the benefits somewhere off in the distance, they still need something to hold them to the vision and see them through the long journey from here to there. Appealing to lofty principles or the bottom line can’t do it, because those approaches too easily give way to forces and considerations that are powerful in the short run even if they are disastrous in the long run.”
I could not disagree with this statement more. Our society is based on bottom lines and lofty principles. Our economy would not be the same; we would not be such a wealthy and prosperous nation if we weren’t based on those things. Johnson does a great job making his argument but I disagree with some of his statements.
Tuesday, January 23, 2007
Framework Essay: Dichotomizing
Framework Essay”: Dichotomizing
After reading the section on dichotomizing I believe that the author did a great job in explain the background of the two parts our society has created. He concludes that not only are these two mutually exclusive classes present but also that there is a gap in the views between different generations of people.
He spent majority of this section not necessarily arguing but making sure that the reader fully understood this concept and how it is present in our society today, as well as, the past actions which have shaped today’s views. The authors views are expressed when he states, “from the essentialist position, race is assumed to exist independently of our perception of it; it is assumed to significantly distinguish one group of people from another. From the constructionist perspective, race exists because we have created it as a meaningful category of difference among people” Even after this statement he never takes a stance on he feels. He only further elaborates on the theory’s that he believes shape the way we view the issue of race and how we dichotomize people.
The one issue that I would have liked if he had addresses further is the difference of opinions between the age gaps. I find this very interested and even more important if analyzing how future generations are going to act toward the current issues of race and dichotomy. How are future generations going to improve the current situation? I believe that the issues of race and dichotomy are slowly improving with each decade but will take tremendous strides to improvement with the new generation. In the essay it discusses how today’s youth of different religions and historical periods are producing other distinctions other than the traditional black and white.
After reading my assigned section I feel better educated on dichotomizing, as well as, past believes and values that have shaped this concept. I also feel that this issue will continue to improve but may never be completely nonexistent. Our society will always see differences whether its race, religion, education, sexuality etc. but how we react to those visible differences will be forever changing.
After reading the section on dichotomizing I believe that the author did a great job in explain the background of the two parts our society has created. He concludes that not only are these two mutually exclusive classes present but also that there is a gap in the views between different generations of people.
He spent majority of this section not necessarily arguing but making sure that the reader fully understood this concept and how it is present in our society today, as well as, the past actions which have shaped today’s views. The authors views are expressed when he states, “from the essentialist position, race is assumed to exist independently of our perception of it; it is assumed to significantly distinguish one group of people from another. From the constructionist perspective, race exists because we have created it as a meaningful category of difference among people” Even after this statement he never takes a stance on he feels. He only further elaborates on the theory’s that he believes shape the way we view the issue of race and how we dichotomize people.
The one issue that I would have liked if he had addresses further is the difference of opinions between the age gaps. I find this very interested and even more important if analyzing how future generations are going to act toward the current issues of race and dichotomy. How are future generations going to improve the current situation? I believe that the issues of race and dichotomy are slowly improving with each decade but will take tremendous strides to improvement with the new generation. In the essay it discusses how today’s youth of different religions and historical periods are producing other distinctions other than the traditional black and white.
After reading my assigned section I feel better educated on dichotomizing, as well as, past believes and values that have shaped this concept. I also feel that this issue will continue to improve but may never be completely nonexistent. Our society will always see differences whether its race, religion, education, sexuality etc. but how we react to those visible differences will be forever changing.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)